After renting a car in the USA numerous times since moving here from Poland two years ago, I’ve learned the ins and outs of the US rental market the hard way. Let me save you from my past mistakes with this comprehensive guide!
Whether you’re planning your first American road trip or just need a refresher on the latest rental policies, I’ve got you covered.
This guide isn’t just theory – it’s packed with real experiences and practical tips I’ve gathered during countless rental experiences.
Essential Requirements for Renting a Car in the USA
Before you even approach the rental counter, make sure you have:
- A valid driver’s license (obviously!)
- A credit card in YOUR name (this is non-negotiable with most companies)
- Proof of insurance – but this only applies if you already have a car in the USA
If you’re visiting from abroad, don’t stress about the insurance part – you’ll simply purchase coverage directly from the rental company.
I once forgot my credit card on a trip to San Francisco and spent three hours desperately calling friends to find a solution. Learn from my mistake!
Foreign Drivers in America – Yes, You Can Drive Here!
Good news for international visitors – you absolutely can drive in the States with your foreign license. Just be aware of some quirky American driving rules that might catch you off guard.
For instance, at four-way stop signs, we follow a “first come, first go” system that caught me by surprise when I first arrived from Poland.
Most mainstream rental companies happily accept foreign licenses, though I’ve encountered exceptions. Some specialty rental companies (like certain Jeep rentals) have insurance that only covers US and Canadian residents.
This isn’t common, but specialized or family-owned rentals might have these limitations.
Renting with a Foreign License – Easier Than You Might Think
In my experience, showing up with a foreign license rarely causes problems. When I first arrived from Poland, I was worried about using my Polish license, but the process was seamless.
While an International Driving Permit (IDP) is technically recommended, I’ve never actually been asked to produce one.
The most “trouble” I’ve encountered was at a smaller rental agency when the agent wasn’t familiar with the format of European licenses – he just asked me to point to the license number and everything was sorted in seconds.
Watch Out For These Rental Gotchas!
The rental price you see online? That’s just the beginning of the story. By the time you leave the counter, expect that number to potentially double after they add:
- Various facility fees
- Insurance (which feels optional but they’ll make sound mandatory)
- State and local taxes
Before driving off, ALWAYS inspect the vehicle thoroughly. Last year in Phoenix, I almost missed a massive scrape along the passenger side. Had I not documented it, I might have been liable for hundreds in “damages” I didn’t cause.
Pro tip that saved me money: When they send you to choose “any car in the row,” scan for the highest-class vehicle.
In Phoenix, I bypassed several economy cars and grabbed a newer model that had somehow ended up in our section – zero extra charge!
Getting the Best Deal Without Breaking the Bank
The rental car pricing system is bizarre and counterintuitive. Recently, I was booking a car at LAX and discovered something strange:
- Next-day rental: $181/week
- One week out: $209/week
- One month ahead: a whopping $412/week
- Three months in advance: an astronomical $593/week
This completely contradicts the conventional wisdom of “book early to save.” Instead, I’ve found success with this strategy: Book something with free cancellation as soon as you know your dates, then keep checking prices weekly.
When you spot a better deal, grab it and cancel the old reservation.
Another trick that saved me nearly $300 last summer: Change your pickup location from the airport to a city location. Yes, you’ll need to Uber there, and yes, they often close early (typically 5 PM), but the savings can be substantial.
I picked up a car in downtown Los Angeles for $290 that would’ve cost $593 at LAX.
Popular Rental Companies and Alternatives
You’re probably familiar with the big names like Hertz, Enterprise, and Avis. They’re popular for good reason – nationwide coverage and generally reliable service.
For something different, consider Turo – essentially the “Airbnb of cars.” I’ve used it a few times now and generally had positive experiences renting directly from car owners.
Understanding Rental Costs
Daily rental rates typically range from $30 for a basic economy car to $100+ for luxury models or SUVs. However, the base rate is just the beginning. Also budget for:
- Insurance ($30-50 daily)
- Taxes (5-15% depending on location)
- Various fees with fancy names (facility charge, anyone?)
Skip the GPS rental – it’s usually $15/day when your phone does the same job perfectly. During a recent road trip through Arizona, Google Maps worked flawlessly even in some pretty remote areas.
Insurance Options Explained (Without the Rental Counter Pressure)
There are three main types of insurance to consider:
- Coverage for the rental car itself – This includes Collision Damage Waiver (CDW) or Loss Damage Waiver(LDW). This covers repair costs if you damage the rental.
- Liability coverage – This kicks in if you damage someone else’s property or injure another person (like if you accidentally back into someone’s car in the hotel parking lot).
- Personal injury protection – Covers medical costs if you’re injured.
If you’re American with your own car insurance, your policy might extend to rentals. Many credit cards also offer coverage if you use them to pay for the rental.
As a foreigner, though, you’ll typically need to purchase insurance from the rental company or a third party.insurance, but as a foreigner, you will need to purchase insurance separately.
Cash or Card?
Despite what you might hope, you can’t just walk up with cash and drive away in a rental car. Credit cards are strongly preferred, though some companies accept debit cards with significant restrictions.
I’ve witnessed people trying to rent with debit cards, and they faced additional credit checks and a much larger hold on their account than those with credit cards. The process typically takes longer too!
Why Are Rental Prices So High Lately?
If you’ve rented cars before and are shocked by current prices, you’re not imagining things. During the pandemic, many rental companies sold off huge portions of their fleets to stay afloat.
When travel rebounded, they faced vehicle shortages due to manufacturing delays and supply chain issues. Simple supply and demand has driven prices up dramatically.
My rental in Los Angeles last year cost nearly twice what I paid for the same car class in 2019. The industry is gradually recovering, but prices remain elevated compared to pre-pandemic levels.
Choosing the Right Vehicle
While economy and compact cars are the most frequently rented categories (and often the cheapest), I’ve found that upgrading to a full-size sedan is usually worth the minimal extra cost – typically just $5-10 more per day.
During a recent road trip across several states, I was infinitely grateful for the additional comfort and trunk space of the mid-size car I’d chosen over the compact I’d initially considered.
Those extra inches make a world of difference on long drives!
Where Can You Take Your Rental?
Generally speaking, you can drive anywhere on paved roads in the United States. Most companies also allow travel into Canada without issues (though always check the policy).
Mexico is a different story – major rental companies typically prohibit taking their vehicles across the southern border. If crossing into Mexico is your plan, you’ll need specialized insurance and permission.
Some companies also restrict travel on unpaved roads. This can become an issue if you want to access certain trailheads in national parks.
If off-road adventures are on your itinerary, confirm the policy or look for specialized rental companies that permit such use.
Is Turo Legitimate?
Yes! Turo (the peer-to-peer car rental platform) is completely legitimate, though it operates differently from traditional rental companies. Instead of renting from a corporation, you’re renting someone’s personal vehicle.
My experiences have ranged from great to adequate. Just be sure to thoroughly document the car’s condition with photos at pickup and dropoff to protect yourself.
Understanding Insurance Terminology
SLI (Supplemental Liability Insurance) provides coverage beyond the state-required minimum for damage you might cause to others or their property. Think of it as extra protection if you accidentally cause a serious accident.
CDW (Collision Damage Waiver) covers damage to your rental car in case of an accident. However, it typically comes with exclusions – it might not cover the roof, tires, windshield, or undercarriage. Read the fine print!
I once declined CDW thinking my credit card coverage was sufficient, only to discover (after a minor fender bender) that my card’s policy had exclusions I hadn’t noticed. That expensive lesson taught me to carefully compare coverage details.
CDW vs. LDW: What’s the Difference?
These terms are often used interchangeably, which adds to the confusion. In general, LDW (Loss Damage Waiver) is slightly more comprehensive, covering both collision damage and theft of the vehicle.
Some companies use only one term or the other, while some offer both with slight differences. When in doubt, ask specifically what scenarios are covered and which parts of the vehicle are excluded.
Avoiding Rental Deposits
Most rental companies place a “hold” on your credit card – essentially a deposit that can range from $200 to over $1,000 depending on the vehicle and rental company.
To avoid this, you can compare different rental companies (some have lower deposit requirements than others) or look into deposit insurance offered by third-party providers like Rentalcars.com or icarhireinsurance.com.
I’ve had success using certain credit cards, which typically result in smaller holds than others. Different companies and different card types can make a substantial difference!
Typical Deposit Amounts
Expect holds ranging from:
- Economy/compact cars: $200-500
- Full-size/premium cars: $300-750
- Luxury vehicles/SUVs: $800-1,500+
These amounts are usually “pre–authorized” rather than actually charged, meaning the funds are reserved but not taken from your account.
The hold is typically released within 3-7 days after returning the car undamaged, though some banks take longer to process the release.
The Credit Card vs. Debit Card Debate
Rental companies strongly prefer credit cards because they can easily place a hold for security without actually charging you. With a debit card, that money is actually removed from your account during the rental period.
If you only have a debit card, expect:
- A larger hold amount
- Possible credit checks
- Additional documentation requirements
- Some companies may refuse altogether
I’ve seen people trying to rent with debit cards have to provide utility bills, proof of return travel, and more documentation just to rent a basic car. The process took nearly an hour longer than credit card rentals.
Travel Budget Calculator
Get your free Travel Budget Calculator now and plan your trip without the stress of overspending!
Final Thoughts on Renting a Car in the USA
Renting a car in the USA remains the most flexible way to explore America’s vastness, from coastal highways to mountain passes that public transportation simply can’t reach.
Despite the occasional frustrations and unexpected costs, the freedom of having your own wheels is unmatched.
As someone who moved to the US from Poland just two years ago, I hope my experiences help smooth your rental process! If you have questions or want to share your own rental car stories or tips, shoot me an email.
And if this guide saved you some headaches, share it with friends planning their American adventures!
Pin it for later!
More articles you might be interested in:
- A 3-Day New York Itinerary You’ll Absolutely Love
- The Ultimate 4-Day Oregon Coast Road Trip Itinerary
- 10 AMAZING Things to Do in Yosemite National Park
- The 10-Day Pacific Northwest Travel Itinerary You’ll Want to Steal
- 10 Absolute Best Joshua Tree National Park Hikes
This article contains affiliate links. If you make a booking through these links, I may earn a commission, supporting this blog. Rest assured, my recommendations are based on honest assessments, and using these links doesn't affect prices for you. Thank you for your support!